I DIDN’T REALIZE THIS UNTIL I GOT YOUR ALL CAPS ASK!
I hadn’t ever thought about it, but you’re right. As of now, I have 4 fics with more comments than kudos.
I’ve been thinking about this, and I see a lot of posts that roll around Tumblr with the same struggle that you’re going through, which is reader feedback.
And I’m gonna be honest with you. Most of the time people complain it’s because they’re not giving back. Look, you as a writer don’t like shouting into the Void, but your readers don’t, either.
If you only reply to your friends, mutuals, regulars, or (even worse) don’t respond at all, then you’re setting yourself up for nothing in return. People will think, at best, that you don’t see it, and at worst, that you don’t care.
Most of the posts I see about leaving comments never addresses the other end of the stick. Yes, we writers spend a lot of time and effort putting our stories out there, but when someone pays you a compliment, you should acknowledge it.
Personally, I’ve run the gamut of comments. I get short and sweet, one word comments, and long rambling keyboard smashing adoration. I’ve also got hate before. But I answer every last comment. It doesn’t take bravery or anything extra to just reply back, “thanks!” That’s literally all you need to do. And sometimes, if I’ve got the time and energy, I’ll address their questions and concerns. There’s really no excuse to thank someone for reading your fic and doing something rare like commenting. NO EXCUSE. You can say thank you. You can put a smiley. You can do literally ANYTHING to tell them you saw it and appreciate it. And if you do, you’ll get 4 fics with more comments than kudos, as well.
‘Cause I’ll tell you something. I commented on a fic once, and it was pretty detailed. Lots of stuff I loved. Then I never got a response. Then I noticed the author picking and choosing comments to respond to that were obviously from people they favored. The rest of us went ignored. Do you think I bothered to comment again? No. Why would I? It impressed to me that the person didn’t care.
Anyway. One word, one emoticon, no excuses, really, If you want people to interact with your stories, you have to let them know that you’ll see it and thank them for it. It’s common decency. Someone’s giving you a treat/gift (a comment), and it’s nice to tell them you got it and appreciate it with a single thank you, if you’re shy. After that, you’ll see more. I promise.